Home » Apple, Handsets, India, News, Nokia

Nokia 5800 vs the Apple iPhone 3G

on January 7, 2009 – 2:02 pm25 Comments

After the comparison between G1 and the iPhone we at Fonearena had presented, here is our comparison of Nokia 5800 with the Apple iPhone 3G

As we had mentioned earlier, regardless of the outcome of the comparative study, Apple should sure be proud of its achievement – of the iPhone setting the benchmark for all future super phones.


Features of iPhone 3G (8GB):

Multimedia – Audio, Video, photo taking and storing, games, applications

Internet/Software – Wi-fi, web browser, Apps store, YouTube, GPS, personal email, Exchange

Input Method – Multi-touch Touch screen

Memory – 8GB

Display Size (diagonal) – 3.5 inches

Dimensions – 115.5X62.1X12.3 mm

Connectivity – USB, 3.55mm (standard) headphone jack, Bluetooth

Battery life – 300 hours standby, 5 hours talk time

Weight – 133 grams

Camera – 2 MP

Colours – White, black

Price – Rs 30,000

Pros

  • Large Display
  • Multi Touch Screen
  • Browser
  • Apps
  • Looks
  • Ipod Music , 3.5mm jack

Cons

  • No Bluetooth for Sharing , only for Headset Pairing
  • No Expandable memory
  • Poor camera and no video or flash
  • Locked and sold only on a contract
  • Expensively Priced
  • No SMS Forwarding


Features of Nokia 5800 Xpress Music:

Multimedia – Audio, Video recording, photos, games, applications

Internet/Software – Wi-fi, web browser, YouTube, GPS, personal email, Exchange, Nokia Maps

Input Method – Multi-touch Touch screen

Memory – 8GB (expandable to 16 GB by microSD card)

Display Size (diagonal) – 3.2 inches

Dimensions – 111X51.7X15.5 mm

Connectivity – USB, 3.55mm (standard) headphone jack, Bluetooth

Battery life – 17 days standby, 9 hours talk time

Weight – 109 grams

Camera – 3.2 MP with Carl Zeiss lens & Dual LED Flash

Price – Rs 22,000 approx

Pros

  • 3.2 MegaPixel Camera with Dual Led Flash with Video Recording
  • Music playback, Store , 3.5mm jack
  • Symbian S60
  • Completely unlocked and no contract needed
  • Expandable memory and USB Mass Storage
  • Cheaper
  • Battery Life
  • Radio

Cons

  • Looks
  • Touch is not comparable to iPhone no Multi Touch
  • Stylus – may be a plus for a few

On the face of it, with a price tag about Rs 8000 less than the iPhone, Nokia 5800 has equivalent features; perhaps even gains a few brownie points OVER the iPhone with its Camera features, battery life and pricing.

But how many will opt for the Nokia in place of the iPhone that is fast becoming a style statement for mobile lovers? Only time will tell !!!

What will you pick for yourself between Nokia 5800 and Apple iPhone 3G ??

Related Posts with Thumbnails



  • http://Houston,TX. Dax

    Ritu,

    You mention in the first para for Nokia 5800 that it has a Multi-touch input method.
    Then, in the cons, you mention that Nokia 5800 lacks Multi-touch ????

    Is it that “copy-pasting” error ?

  • http://www.fonearena.com Varun

    @Dax

    Read carefully ,

    the first portion of the article talks about iphone 3g and 2nd part about nokia 5800.

    i think you are seeing pros of iphone 3g and cons of nokia 5800 :)

    Im i right ?

    And if you can write well , please contact us and we can see if you are qualified

  • Georgy

    Don’t just buy iphone as a status symbol.. I doubt in your words which stress more on pros of iphone&cons of 5800..
    Nokia 5800 rocks…!

  • Georgy

    Don’t just buy iphone as a status symbol.. Its not having bluetooth,video recording,even no sms fwding..&3G’s not yet available here..
    Nokia 5800 rocks…!

  • http://inday-stories.blogspot.com inday

    i’ve been reading a lot of reviews and comparisons between nokia 5800 and iphone.. Nokia 5800 keeps winning.. it surely is a great phone and i wanna have one for myself..:)

  • Jonna

    Alright, Just want to know are you guys talking about two phones?
    Which usually i use for answering a call or to call someone…… Then you are talking about something else. coz i use my phone for this purpose only. next everybody is talking about SMS forwarding…. I hardly sent SMS out from my mobile forget about forwarding. Now, bluetooth, i use my bluetooth only for the head phones which iphone supports. well, think in this way you love The iPhone.

  • Jonna

    guys forgot to mention one thing. Someone is talking about Status…..!. you better purchase China mobile that works better than any mobile.

  • Unknown

    Guys, i am thinking bewteen iphone and express 5800 , but i went to 20+ websites and most of the comments says that 5800 is better than iphone but i like iphone because you can go youtube , but its uses is much lesser and lousier than express 5800 phone . So which should i choose !! help me !!! 50-50 !! Holy i can afford both as the new iphone is coming out and the old iphone price went down ALOT!! ^_^

  • http://www.uga.com uga

    hi,

    forget all these just buy n 97 u will get all features
    but price is some what high

  • nvr

    yuppp……….nokia 5800 always rocks……i phone really sux!….

  • umie_XM

    i already own nokia 5800 for about past couple weeks..
    and it’s amazing…
    suitable for young people like me a.k.a a teenager
    still the functions suits every needs even for an adult/worker..
    ehe..just wanna share that..
    iphone still ok but i think btter choose nokia 5800 ..no offense
    :)

  • Gaurav Grover

    guys guys guys……….u ll confusd me….but i think nokia 5800 is a better option.

  • anwar

    yah, because not all people using a phone act same as u are.

    nokia 5800 near to perfection

  • Gaurav

    u dont have money to buy an iphone so u r keep on yelling tht 5800roxx nd all tht shit !!
    i have iphone 3gs 16gb nd i bought it for 36000 as compared to price of 5800>>rs 13000
    iphone is arount 3 times d cost of 5800 but trust me it worth more thn that !!!
    apple is planning nxt model of iphone nd trust me i’ll definately buy tht !!

    nd yea 1 task i give to u>>

    compare ovi store of nokia nd app store of apple !!!if u really wanna know wht money can buy !!!!

  • http://geekbattlefield.com r00t

    I own both :) iPhone to make calls and to show on public :) , Nokia for GPS and internet surfung.
    However, my vote goes to iPhone in this round.

  • selvarajan

    iPhone is for dumb guys Even a school kid knows that even Nokia low end phones have better feature than iphone – No video, bluetooth can’t transfer files, No video recording, SMS forwadring absent , NO MULTI TASKING ( U have to close one app to open another)
    Those who want to impress dumb gals go for iphone, those who love technology & intelligent girls go for Nokia 5800!

  • selvarajan

    You paid 36000 for a mobile which can’t record a video, which can’t transfer files via bluetooth, which can’t multitask (run apps simultaneously),which has no Voice Navigation for GPS, which can’t even view flash files on web, which needs $$$ for playing proprietary music formats – I can understand an American buying it – God made them a fool- but an Indian?

  • selvarajan

    Vote goes for iphone? Hmmm obviously you r one of those who needs to be in asylum

  • Rajiv

    ya true i wonder how much an iphone will cost with 8MP camera 1lakh Rs. I guess lol and u took of applications how many of those crap applications are useful

  • DCSUMAILI

    NOKIA IS THE WINNER NO DOUBT.

  • http://google kumar Gaurav

    Guys i must say the nokia 5800 is clear winer

  • http://www.wimaxbsnl.blogspot.com ALBERT

    My vote Nor for Iphone or n5800 its only for Selvarajan..!

  • Stephen

    For me 5800 is far more better than iphone in many aspects.5800 Rocks!!!

  • Vasu

    Hi,
    confuse about nokia 5800 and iphone 3g.
    No confuse.
    i will clear you.just put two phones in 3 feet hight.
    which switch off first is looser.
    You have not enough money too .
    Just go to u tube . And watch 5800 or iphone crashing or breaking vedios! Then take your own decision.

  • Vasu

    Hi,
    confuse about nokia 5800 and iphone 3g.
    No confuse.
    i will clear you.just put two phones in 3 feet hight.
    which switch off first is looser.
    You have not enough money too .
    Just go to u tube . And watch 5800 or iphone crashing or breaking vedios! Then take your own decision. .