Sony Ericsson Satio VS Nokia N97, 5800 XpressMusic And X6
Email This Post
| 14 Comments
Yes, you read that post title right. We outdid ourselves, by a long shot on this article. Not only did we land a prototype of the Sony Ericsson Satio and show it to you in intricate details, but we were also able to pit it head to head against its concurrence, with Nokia’s current lineup of similar S60 5th Edition devices: the Nokia N97, 5800 XpressMusic and the most recent X6.
The comparison will look shortly at the software differences between the Satio and the current S60 5th Edition UI from Nokia (which we will develop in another post with some very long video reviews), then it will focus at the hardware side-by-side comparison with the 3 devices.
S60 5th Edition Software UI Comparison: Sony Ericsson vs Nokia
The first thing you will notice when launching the Satio is a different homescreen from the usual S60 5th edition one were’s used to on Nokia devices. This homescreen is divided in 5 panes (5 icons on the top) that are Contacts, Bookmarks, Main Homescreen, Photos and Applications. The Main homescreen has an integrated Music Player widget and a quick access to the Dial-Pad, Media Browser, Messaging and Search function. In comparison, the homescreen on the 5800 Xpress Music is dull with a couple of application screenshots, Search, Email and Calendar, with quick access to the Dial-Pad and Contacts.
The Menu UI and most of its structure is very similar between both variants of S60 5th.
The Gallery on the Satio is divided in 3 main views: Photos, Music and Video, and uses a whole different UI system than the Gallery on Nokia’s Symbian devices.
Next up is Gravity, the Twitter client, running on both devices side by side, and proving that applications written for S60 5th Edition are not only compatible with Nokia’s devices, but also with the Satio from SE.
We won’t go into more details in this post, as we have prepared some video reviews of the Satio’s UI in action, so keep you eyes on FoneArena for that 
Side by Side comparison: Satio vs Nokia N97
The two flagships go head to head here, or side by side if you want. We can see that although the frontal size of the twi is very similar, the N97’s rounded angles make it look and feel much smaller than the Satio that has very square and angled corners. The Satio hence comes out as an imposing handset, whereas the N97 looks more hand-friendly. In terms of materials, both devices rely heavily on good material plastic, a nice clear screen cover, and some metallic accents.
Although both devices have almost the same thickness, they use it differently. The N97 embodies a slide-out qwerty keyboard, whereas the Satio’s thickness is mostly in the top part due to its sliding camera cover that protects the 12MP lens module.
Both handsets feature a flicking keylock on their left side, the N97 has the standard microUSB port to connect with the computer and to charge it, whereas the Satio has the more archaic pop-port connector. It also has a microSDHC slot.
The bottom side on both devices is clean of connectors or buttons.
The right side is where a great difference can be observed. Like the N97, the Satio has volume keys (also used for zooming) and a dedicated camera key, but this one is circled by an LED light that turns blue when the camera is in action, and it also has a Photo gallery quick access key, and a dedicated photo/video capture switch for the Camera.
On the top, you can see the power button on both handsets, as well as a 3.5mm headset plug on the N97. The Satio uses its pop-port for music headsets.
Side by Side comparison: Satio vs Nokia X6
The Satio and the Nokia X6 share a very similar rectangular design and form factor, the Satio though is a a bit bigger (not as much as the first image shows, the Satio was placed closer to the camera than the X6), longer, larger, but also way more thick. The main unit on the Satio (without the camera cover) is almost the same thickness as the X6, but add it, and you have a lot of bulk showing up. Another main difference is also with the X6 having 3 touch-sensitive keys (call/menu/end call), whereas the Satio has hardware buttons.
Side by Side comparison: Satio vs Nokia 5800 XpressMusic
The Satio outperforms the 5800 XpressMusic in nearly all aspects, yet still manages to be only a bit bigger. Take a look at the images below to see for yourself how a 3.2MP plastic-covered cameraphone looks next to a 12MP metal clad device.
What are your opinions of the Satio after seeing it next to its competitors? Are y put off by its size, or willing to compromize given the many features it offers?
Email This Post
Thanks for these comparison shots. I dig the SE Satio, but I think I prefer the overall UI and design of the N97 , though I do think Gravity looks a tad bit better on the Satio. The Satio’s size is fine with me, it’s the UI that’s lacking.
would like that you add the omnia hd too here, anyway..
No the Satio’s tiny battery is a deal breaker for me, plus i really hate the properity connectors.
I’m happy with my omniaHD and it’s custom rom
well they look so dull before the satio in almost every aspect, superb phone i must admit……….
the display of the 5800 is better to compare with the satio (at least)
than the n97 which doesnt even come close in resolution…
@Varun
Can u publish an article on the “Samsung Omnia Lite”, i want to know more about it????
About what comes in the box…..how it is as a phone…other features..it’s a WM phone so I would really like to know….
Reply soon….
Will try our best to get our hands of the device ! cheers
wht the hell….u compered the gr8 SE Satio with crap Nokia 5800
It like u r comparing Tendulkar with Freddy
freddy is also one of the greatest allrounders of all time isnt it?? common Satio is light years better but it doesnt give to compare it atleast as they are of the same characteristic feature..
Satio nd omniahd is better thn these phn’s.
Waow, Satio (Idou) is the best Camera phone ever. No comparison.
Great work by Sony Ericsson. What is the current price in Dubai, United Arab Emirates?
I think the 5800 was only added to show the differences in UI.
I personally was looking forward to the Satio untill I heard of the X6. That’s when i was met with the dilema of which device to spend my hard earned cash on. Since both use the S60 5th ed. in an almost identical fashion, they are pretty much the same phone. The only important differences (to me) are the type of touch screen, the onboard memory and the camera (To me the ability to link with a ps3 is redundant since the Satio is not the “psp phone” that some of us were looking forward to).
So with that in m ind, I’m assuming that the X6 will have the same 5mp camera as was on the N95 which was an excelent standard for camera phones at the time, but the sony ericsson K800’s 3mp cybershot camera was so good that it rivaled and in some cases even surpassed the N95’s 5mp camera. With that in mind, I have no doubt that the Satio’s 12mp cybershot camera is going to absolutley blow the X6’s away. However, If i really want the higher quality pics, I could just follow the pro’s shocking advice of getting… wait for it!… AN ACTUAL CAMERA!! Shocking, I know.
Memory is very important to me, since I’ve always used my smartphones for work, vidoes and music on the go, rather than buying a big weighty laptop or a netbook which tries to fill a gap that smartphones are soon likely to conquer. Although the Satio comes with an 8gig card, the 32gig X6 wins.
As for Capacitive vs Resistive, I dont have the glove problem since I live in a nice & warm environment
but I do prefer the more precise resitive screens, since it makes text editing a little less frustrating (…Another reason to give up smatphones for netbooks).
The Nokia’s 3.5mm headphones vs the SE’s proprietary headseat arugument is redundant to us fans of cable-free stereo bluetooth headsets. But since the X6’s 3.5mm plug supports video out, that’s another win for the X6.
Since I must always consider the value of every purchase, the cheaper X6 (going by estimated prices on the net) is the most likely to win my money and if the rest of the world will be patient enough to wait a few weeks for November 12, then I think that Sony Ericsson will be looking at yet another painful defeat.
superb fone….i wud like to have a satio….elegant looks ……….
Satio is the best!
im in love with this!
nokia n97, 5800 express music,x6 and samsung omnia, omnia hd sucks!
it would b much better if u replace fking 5800 express with SE Aino
in this comparison.
i guess u havent tried the omnia hd..
so maybe u should keep ur views with u..